Now I have to say my opinion .
I have had problems with the design on A3 and Im with Klier when he says its the least attractive car from Audi and the A3 Convertible is even more boring car to look at. A3 and me dont get along. I drove several A3 before I bought my babybimmer and neither gearbox, steering or driving experience was on the same level as 1-series IMO.

With that said I havent driven S3 but I believe its a better drive than any lower A3 model and lot sportier drive than the weaker engines from A3. I also think it looks pretty good, particulary in black. But I can't see why I would pick a S3 over a more modern and fresh 135i.